Shakespeare for All Time

"Why man, he doth bestride the narrow world like a Colossus."


  • Home
  • About
  • Plays
    • Chronology
    • Summaries
    • The Tragedies
    • The Histories
    • The Comedies
  • Poems
    • The Rape of Lucrece
    • Venus and Adonis
    • The Phoenix and the Turtle
    • A Lover’s Complaint
  • Sonnets
    • To a Young Man Urging Marriage
    • To a Young Man, Various Themes
    • To the “Dark Lady”
  • Sources
    • Histories
    • Comedies
    • Tragedies
  • Resources
    • Shakespeare Festivals and Theaters
    • General Online Resources
    • Educational Resources
  • Criticism
  • Movies
  • Biography
  • Recitals
  • FAQs
  • Blog
  • “He” in MacDuff’s “He Has No Children”

    Peter , Monday, April 15, 2013 / Macbeth

    In A.C. Bradley’s Shakespearean Tragedy – a must read for all who have read the four great tragedies: Hamlet, Othello, King Lear and Macbeth – he discusses the following passage in which Macduff reacts to the news that Macbeth has slain his wife and children:

    Malcom.   Be comforted: Let’s make us medicines of our great revenge, to cure this deadly grief.

    Macduff.   He has no children. All my pretty ones? Did you say all? O hell-kite! All? What, all my pretty chickens and their dam at one fell swoop?

    Malcom.   Dispute it like a man.

    Macduff.   I shall do so; But I must also feel it as a man: I cannot but remember such things were, that were most precious to me. —

    Who is Macduff speaking of when he says “He has no children?” Bradley offers and analyzes the three possible interpretations:

    (a) They refer to Malcolm, who, if he had children of his own, would not at such a moment suggest revenge, or talk of curing such a grief. Cf. King John, III. iv. 91, where Pandulph says to Constance,

    “You hold too heinous a respect of grief,”

    and Constance answers,

    “He talks to me that never had a son”

    (b) They refer to Macbeth, who has no children, and on whom therefore Macduff cannot take an adequate revenge.

    (c) They refer to Macbeth, who, if he himself had children, could never have ordered the slaughter of children.  Cf. 3 Henry VI. V. v. 63, where Margaret says to the murderers of Prince Edward,

    “You have no children, butchers! if you had, The thought of them would have stirred up remorse.”

    Bradley makes short shrift of choice (b) simply by pointing out that everything in the text indicates that Macduff is not the kind of man who would kill someone’s children for revenge:

    Macduff is not the man to conceive at any time the idea of killing children in retaliation; and that he contemplates it here, even as a suggestion, I find it hard to believe.

    I would add that Macduff is a noble personage in Macbeth. Shakespeare makes him noble to put Macbeth’s ignobility in high relief. Having Macduff express a desire to kill Macbeth’s children would have been inconsistent with Macduff’s role in the play.

    The first time I read Macbeth I was certain that Macduff’s words “He has no children” meant that Macbeth was capable of killing Macduff’s children only because he himself had no children. In other words, for Macduff, only a man who had not experienced parental love could murder a child. Now, after re-reading Bradley’s notes on Macbeth, I am not so sure.

    The principal objection to choice a) is syntactical. If Macduff is speaking to Malcom, the argument goes, why would he refer to him as “he” rather than “you.” In other words, choice a) can’t be correct, because if it were, Shakespeare would have had Macduff say “You have no children” not “He has no children.” Bradley, the closest of close readers, notes that there are several other instances where Shakespeare has a character refer to the person he is speaking to in the third person:

    It has been objected to interpretation (a) that, according to it, Macduff would naturally say ‘You have no children,’ not ‘He has no children.’ But what Macduff does is precisely what Constance does in the line quoted [above] from King John.

    Bradley also posits that in this exchange Macbeth is addressing the messenger, Ross, not Malcom, who joins the conversation only at the end via interruption,

    [A]ll through the passage down to this point, and indeed in the fifteen lines which precede our quotation, Macduff listens only to Ross. His questions ‘My children too?’ ‘My wife killed too?’ show that he cannot fully realize what he is told. When Malcolm interrupts, therefore, he puts aside his suggestion with four words spoken to himself, or (less probably) to Ross (his relative, who knew his wife and children), and continues his agonized questions and exclamations. Surely it is not likely that at that moment the idea of (c), an idea which there is nothing to suggest, would occur to him.

    Based on Bradley’s exegesis, I now tend to favor choice a) . . . but only on those days that I do not favor choice c).

    Tags: · a.c. bradley, he has no children, macbeth, macduff, shakespearean tragedy
    → No Comments




Subscribe to our RSS Feed Subscribe in a Feeder

Recent Posts

  • Shakespeare, Shylock and Anti-Semitism
  • Greenblatt: Shakespeare’s Freedom
  • Who Really Lost Othello’s Handkerchief?
  • Falstaff, Lord of Misrule
  • Othello and Brown v Board of Education
  • Bottom’s Dream
  • Is Prince Hal a Realistic Character?
  • Comparing Hamlets: Benedict Cumberbatch
  • New Historicism & Confirmation Bias
  • Acting Shakespeare: Hall’s Pause
SHAKESPEARE PERFORMED! William Shakespeare
Listen to and watch recordings of your favorite monologues and soliloquies.

Comments

  • John on Cry Havoc and Let Slip the Dogs of War
  • Richard H. Baum on More Honor’d in the Breach
  • Jocelyn on Cry Havoc and Let Slip the Dogs of War
  • Ethan Bosmeny on Shakespeare’s Karma
  • Shakespeare for All Time » Blog Archive Greenblatt: Shakespeare's Freedom - Shakespeare for All Time on Kermode: Writing about Shakespeare
  • Shakespeare for All Time » Blog Archive Greenblatt: Shakespeare's Freedom - Shakespeare for All Time on New Historicism & Confirmation Bias
  • Nicholas Dunne-Lynch on Shakespeare’s Source for Othello: Cinthio
  • Rose on Does Lady Macbeth Really Faint?
  • Basil on Cry Havoc and Let Slip the Dogs of War
  • Thilliar Varnakulasingham on
    Frequently Asked Questions

Affiliations

  • British Shakespeare Society
  • Folger Shakespeare Library
  • Royal Shakespeare Company
  • Shakespeare Association of America
  • Shakespeare Society
  • Shakespeare Society of America

Blogroll

  • American Shakespeare Center
  • Blogging Shakespeare
  • Enfolded Hamlet
  • I Love Shakespeare
  • Mad Shakespeare
  • No Sweat Shakespeare
  • Play Shakespeare
  • Shakespeare Geek
  • Shakespeare Online Resources
  • Shakespeare Theaters
  • Shakespeare's Editors
  • Shakespeare's Sonnets
  • Shakespeare's Words
  • The Bardathon
  • The Shakespeare Birthplace Trust
  • The Shakespeare Blog
  • What's It All About, Shakespeare?

Scholars & Critics

  • Marjorie Garber
  • Peter Kirwan

Categories

  • Authorship
  • Coriolanus
  • Criticism
  • Falstaff
  • Hamlet
  • Henry IV
  • Henry VI
  • Julius Caesar
  • King Lear
  • Macbeth
  • Measure for Measure
  • Merchant of Venice
  • Midsummer Night's Dream
  • Othello
  • Performing Shakespeare
  • Podcasts
  • Poems
  • Reading Shakespeare
  • Recitals
  • Romeo & Juliet
  • Shakespeare and Freud
  • Shakespeare and Philosophy
  • Shakespeare and Politics
  • Shakespeare and the Law
  • Shakespeare Humor
  • Shakespeare on Film
  • Shakespeare's Imagery
  • Shakespeare's Life
  • Shakespeare's Sources
  • Shakespeare's Women
  • Shakespeares Phrases
  • The Tempest
  • Titus Anrdronicus

Archives

  • November 2016
  • April 2016
  • March 2016
  • February 2016
  • November 2015
  • April 2015
  • December 2014
  • April 2013
  • June 2012
  • February 2012
  • January 2012
  • December 2011
Topics
  • Authorship
  • Coriolanus
  • Criticism
  • Falstaff
  • Hamlet
  • Henry IV
  • Henry VI
  • Julius Caesar
  • King Lear
  • Macbeth
  • Measure for Measure
  • Merchant of Venice
  • Midsummer Night's Dream
  • Othello
  • Performing Shakespeare
  • Podcasts
  • Poems
  • Reading Shakespeare
  • Recitals
  • Romeo & Juliet
  • Shakespeare and Freud
  • Shakespeare and Philosophy
  • Shakespeare and Politics
  • Shakespeare and the Law
  • Shakespeare Humor
  • Shakespeare on Film
  • Shakespeare's Imagery
  • Shakespeare's Life
  • Shakespeare's Sources
  • Shakespeare's Women
  • Shakespeares Phrases
  • The Tempest
  • Titus Anrdronicus
Blogroll
  • American Shakespeare Center
  • Blogging Shakespeare
  • Enfolded Hamlet
  • I Love Shakespeare
  • Mad Shakespeare
  • No Sweat Shakespeare
  • Play Shakespeare
  • Shakespeare Geek
  • Shakespeare Online Resources
  • Shakespeare Theaters
  • Shakespeare's Editors
  • Shakespeare's Sonnets
  • Shakespeare's Words
  • The Bardathon
  • The Shakespeare Birthplace Trust
  • The Shakespeare Blog
  • What's It All About, Shakespeare?
Affiliations
  • British Shakespeare Society
  • Folger Shakespeare Library
  • Royal Shakespeare Company
  • Shakespeare Association of America
  • Shakespeare Society
  • Shakespeare Society of America
Most Recent Posts
  • Shakespeare, Shylock and Anti-Semitism
  • Greenblatt: Shakespeare’s Freedom
  • Who Really Lost Othello’s Handkerchief?
  • Falstaff, Lord of Misrule
  • Othello and Brown v Board of Education
  • Bottom’s Dream
  • Is Prince Hal a Realistic Character?
  • Comparing Hamlets: Benedict Cumberbatch
  • New Historicism & Confirmation Bias
  • Acting Shakespeare: Hall’s Pause
  • A Ranking of Shakespeare’s Plays
  • Shakespeare’s Source for Othello: Cinthio
  • Juliet’s Virginity, Or Lack Thereof
  • Kermode: Writing about Shakespeare
  • The Rejection of Falstaff
  • Macbeth
  • Did Arizona Ban The Tempest?
  • Bloom: Shakespeare Presaged Freud
  • Happy Birthday, Bard
  • Killer of Speech Terrain
  • On What Stone is it Etched
  • Murder Should be Loathsome
  • Boyish Dreams
  • Man is But a Talking Beast
  • Writing about Shakespeare
Shakespeare for All Time is published by Bard Publishing, LLC, a Florida Limited Liability Company, Orlando, Florida
© 2019 Shakespeare for All Time All Rights Reserved.